A Jefferson County man is suing Gov. Greg Gianforte for appointing a state legislator to lead the Montana Department of Commerce.
Commerce Director Marta Bertoglio was appointed June 16, a couple hours after resigning her Montana House seat representing Jefferson County. One of the former representative’s constituents, Jordan Williams, argues that the Montana Constitution’s “disqualification provision” bans legislators from appointments to state civil office.
In a lawsuit filed Wednesday in Lewis and Clark County District Court, Jordan asks that Bertoglio, a three-term lawmaker from Clancy, be stopped from working at Commerce and that the Department of Administration be blocked from paying the former representative.
The governor’s general counsel, Anita Milanovich, countered in a letter to Williams’ attorney that state civil office positions are independent and not overseen by someone with superior power. The governor oversees the commerce director, Milanovich argues, which means Bertoglio doesn’t act independently.
The Bertoglio appointment marks the fourth time Gianforte has appointed a state legislator to a position within state government. The lure of state employment has the potential to influence lawmakers’ decisions, argued attorney Andres Haladay with Upper Seven Law on behalf of Williams.
“Unconstitutional gubernatorial appointments send the message that part-time citizen legislators — who in 2025 made a salary of $128.86 per day — might win a six-figure golden ticket to an appointed state civil office if they promote [the] governor’s political interests over the needs of their own constituents,” Haladay said in the lawsuit. The other three appointees were former Rep. Jimmy Patelis, R-Billings, appointed to the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole in 2021, former Sen. Bob Brown, R-Trout Creek, appointed Montana Lottery director in 2024; and former Rep. Paul Green, R-Hardin, also appointed commerce director in 2024.
latest stories
Where does eastern Montana start? Montanans disagree
Montana is in many ways a land of two halves: a western Montana of snow-capped mountains and national forests joined in political unity with an eastern Montana of wide-open plains and flatland agriculture. It’s a time-honored divide: peaks versus plains, Missoula versus Miles City, Flathead versus Fort Peck lakes. But where exactly is the dividing line?
Most Montana voters don’t want a statewide sales tax
Nearly half of Montana voters say they “strongly oppose” the notion of a statewide sales tax — even if the revenues are used to reduce property tax bills.
Montana voters overwhelmingly view cost as a major mental health care hurdle
According to a Montana Free Press-Eagleton Poll, conducted in late 2025 and early 2026, 67% of respondents cited “cost of services” as a major problem when it comes to accessing care. A smaller share, 42%, cited the stigma associated with receiving care as a major problem, while 47% said the same about the travel distance necessary to access services.